Coolant temp and thermostats, etc.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Duke W.
    Beyond Control Poster
    • January 1, 1993
    • 15229

    #1

    Coolant temp and thermostats, etc.

    Engine coolant temperature concerns seems to be a recurring theme, and we've had lots of discussions on senders, gages, fans, fan shrouds, radiators, antifreeze, and additives, but the one thing that no one has ever mentioned is how thermostats work.

    If you have a 180 degree thermostat that doesn't necessarily mean the temp will always run at 180. What it means is that the thermostat BEGINS to open at 180 degrees. I don't have a set of specs for a 180, but a typical OEM GM 195 thermostat is speced to begin opening a 192 to 198 and is not full open until about 225 to 230, so maximum coolant flow does not occur until the outlet temp hits this range. The 180 would have similar specs only about 15 degrees cooler on all specs.

    When our cars were new they would usually stay pretty close to 180, but as time goes by scales form in cooling system components which tends to raise temperatures. It's always a worry when you see the needle creep up in hot weather, particularly low speed traffic, but maybe we're over reacting.

    GM says that engine friction, particularly ring and skirt drag, is less with higher coolant temperature, so best power is usually obtained with high coolant temps. A 50/50 mixture of glycol and water boils at 265 degrees with a 15 pound cap, so if you have a 180 thermostat and the temp. goes up to 220 or 230 occasionally, especially at idle in hot weather, it's probably no big deal. In fact, it's common on modern cars. If the fan, shroud, coolant pump, radiator, cap and other cooling system components check out, I don't think we should worry that much. Beyond this, if you have any emission controls, such as TCS or the vacuum advance running on an off idle port, rework it so you have full vacuum advance at idle. This will always reduce idle and low speed coolant temperature.

    Okay, now I'll go put on my nomex before I check back for responses.

    Duke
  • Joe L.
    Beyond Control Poster
    • February 1, 1988
    • 42936

    #2
    Re: Coolant temp and thermostats, etc.

    Duke-----

    I completely agree. Also, I'd make a fact clear that a lot of folks don't seem to appreciate: a thermostat only controls the MINIMUM temperature that an engine will operate at after warming up. It has no relevance or control, whatsoever, with respect to the MAXIMUM temperature that an engine may reach. Once the thermostat is FULL OPEN, the thermostat's job is done with respect to regulating engine temperature.
    In Appreciation of John Hinckley

    Comment

    • Martin M.
      Very Frequent User
      • November 1, 1979
      • 124

      #3
      Robertshaw fast opening thermostats

      HI Duke:

      We had a little talk about thermostats on the garage roof at Tahoe. The Robertshaw thermostat I mentioned is a fast opening type, and is supposed to eliminate the delay and subsequent temperature rise. I have used them in my hot rodding days, and currently have them in my Chev duallie, and in the '63 cvt we were driving at Tahoe. In both cases the temp was lowered by 10 degrees, and does not fluctuate. Living just outside Las Vegas certainly puts these vehicles to the test. Such a simple thing is usually ignored until everything else is tried. It is the first thing I do if I am having temp problems.

      Marty
      Beautiful Pahrump, NV.
      No smog, no rain, no winter, no hurricanes, no tornadoes,
      no earthquakes, no forest fires, but prime rib 24/7, and an NHL hockey team in LV.

      vetteheads.com alumni, Boston MA alumni
      1963 NOM Split, 1963 Orig Split 340, 1963 Red Vert Ex NCM opening display car
      1970 Coupe, 1985 Coupe Road Warrior, 1986 Vert
      1932 Ford Highboy Roadster TPI, 1932 Chev 4 Dr Confederate Sedan
      1957 Chrysler 300 C 392 Hemi Car
      All for sale - most not cheap!!!

      Comment

      • Joe L.
        Beyond Control Poster
        • February 1, 1988
        • 42936

        #4
        Re: Robertshaw fast opening thermostats

        Marty-----

        Yes, the Robertshaw thermostats are excellent. Not only the "quick opening" feature, but also a larger effective opening to ease tha passage of coolant. I discovered them years ago, too. Rare is it that I deviate from GM/Delco, but this is one of those "special" cases.
        In Appreciation of John Hinckley

        Comment

        • Michael R.
          Expired
          • April 1, 2000
          • 0

          #5
          Re: Coolant temp and thermostats, etc.

          Hmmm..I'm not sure I'd agree with you on this, Duke..It's been my experience a cooler fuel charge and lower temps provide more power and reduce detonation, especially on cast iron motors... STW, Mike

          Comment

          • motorman

            #6
            Re: Robertshaw fast opening thermostats

            i have used a 195 RS thermo in my C-2500 pickup and it keeps the temp down under 200 degrees in the heat of summer towing my trailer, but i have to put in a std. 195 GM thermo in the winter or the temp never goes over 150/160 degrees. the truck is equipted with the trailer towing package and has a large rad, engine oil cooler and a trans cooler.

            Comment

            • Duke W.
              Beyond Control Poster
              • January 1, 1993
              • 15229

              #7
              You and Chevrolet Engr. are both correct

              Mike - It's axiomatic that cooler air and fuel will yield a denser mixture and more power. And it's Chevrolet Engineering that says a hotter jacket temperature reduces internal friction, which makes more usable power. That's why a carbureted racing engine has blocked (or no) heat riser passages and cold air induction. When running at WOT there is so much air flowing through the inlet system aided by the cooling of the fuels latent heat of vaporization that it stays quite cool. A case in point is my Cosworth Vega. Because it has EFI it has no coolant or exhaust inlet manifold heating, and after running a twenty minute hot lap session at Willow Springs the inlet manifold is cool to the touch back in the paddock, despite a coolant temperature of up to 210. A "V" type engine manifold will likely run a little hotter because more of the manifold's surface area is exposed to hot engine components, and that's why the Hi Perf aluminum manifolds have a heat shield on the bottom.

              Duke

              Comment

              • motorman

                #8
                Re: You and Chevrolet Engr. are both correct

                most race engines on the dyno make the best power at 200/210 degrees water,220/250 degree oil temp, but with cold air inlet temp. that is why manifold with a air gap under the make the most hp. higher oil temp seem to be the secret as low oil temp really kills HP. on a 600+ hp engine i have seen 18 hp difference with hotter oil.

                Comment

                • Martin M.
                  Very Frequent User
                  • November 1, 1979
                  • 124

                  #9
                  Re: Robertshaw fast opening thermostats

                  Motorman:

                  I have the same situation on my duallie. I have installed a vinyl radiator block in front of the grilles with snaps. Seems to do the trick.

                  Marty
                  Beautiful Pahrump, NV.
                  No smog, no rain, no winter, no hurricanes, no tornadoes,
                  no earthquakes, no forest fires, but prime rib 24/7, and an NHL hockey team in LV.

                  vetteheads.com alumni, Boston MA alumni
                  1963 NOM Split, 1963 Orig Split 340, 1963 Red Vert Ex NCM opening display car
                  1970 Coupe, 1985 Coupe Road Warrior, 1986 Vert
                  1932 Ford Highboy Roadster TPI, 1932 Chev 4 Dr Confederate Sedan
                  1957 Chrysler 300 C 392 Hemi Car
                  All for sale - most not cheap!!!

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  Searching...Please wait.
                  An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because you have logged in since the previous page was loaded.

                  Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                  An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because the token has expired.

                  Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                  An internal error has occurred and the module cannot be displayed.
                  There are no results that meet this criteria.
                  Search Result for "|||"