Dragging Starter - NCRS Discussion Boards

Dragging Starter

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Paul A.
    Very Frequent User
    • April 21, 2021
    • 227

    Dragging Starter

  • Stephen L.
    Extremely Frequent Poster
    • May 31, 1984
    • 3148

    #2
    Re: Dragging Starter

    Sounds like you still have a "starter" problem. Even "rebuilt" starters can experience "heat soak" which I think is your problem. ( I don't know if a rebuilder can, or perform a heat soak during a rebuild) I would purchase another starter (generic) as a test. Install it and see if the problem is resolved. You might also visit the local rebuilder and discuss your problem....... you are NOT the first to experience this.... I've had the same problem with a BB Chevrolet........ Remember the engine starter worked great for most of its life........

    Heat soak is winding resistance goes up with temp.........

    Comment

    • Paul A.
      Very Frequent User
      • April 21, 2021
      • 227

      #3
      Re: Dragging Starter

      Will do. I’ve never thought of swapping out starter with another generic. What’s you feelings on the mini starter idea?

      Comment

      • Stephen L.
        Extremely Frequent Poster
        • May 31, 1984
        • 3148

        #4
        Re: Dragging Starter

        As I said, the original starter from the factory worked great in millions of Chevrolets for years. A mini starter may be needed if the compression has been significantly increased. Otherwise ???????

        Comment

        • Larry M.
          Extremely Frequent Poster
          • January 1, 1992
          • 2688

          #5
          Re: Dragging Starter

          Advanced initial timing @16 BTDC is also not helping. You might try and see if reducing to say 12 degrees helps any. If so, centrifugal advance curve can be re-adjusted to keep total number the same.

          I would also inquire to see if your local starter shop can rebuild for additional load/torque. I had this done for my small block car...........but it was essentially rebuilt to big block specs. But perhaps your rebuilder knows of a few tricks that still can be done.

          Larry

          Comment

          • Ronald L.
            Extremely Frequent Poster
            • October 18, 2009
            • 3248

            #6
            Re: Dragging Starter

            I had same issue 15 years ago with my survivor 390HP, all that was required was new brushes in the starter, they had worn down and "shorting" the insulation gaps. Even back decades ago with the best Hydraulic BB cam and a few other enhancements, these cars started fine with a stock starter. I'd really look at the rebuild, I had them put GM NOS brushes in mine.

            Comment

            • Leif A.
              Extremely Frequent Poster
              • August 31, 1997
              • 3607

              #7
              Re: Dragging Starter

              Originally posted by Larry Mulder (20401)
              Advanced initial timing @16 BTDC is also not helping. You might try and see if reducing to say 12 degrees helps any. If so, centrifugal advance curve can be re-adjusted to keep total number the same.

              I would also inquire to see if your local starter shop can rebuild for additional load/torque. I had this done for my small block car...........but it was essentially rebuilt to big block specs. But perhaps your rebuilder knows of a few tricks that still can be done.

              Larry
              ^^^This. Any competent rebuilder should be able to do this...it's been done umpteen times over the years.
              Leif
              '67 Coupe L79, M21, C60, N14, N40, J50, A31, U69, A01, QB1
              Top Flight 2017 Lone Star Regional

              Comment

              • Alan D.
                Extremely Frequent Poster
                • January 1, 2005
                • 2027

                #8
                Re: Dragging Starter

                Try spacer on starter, try some search's for this a common problem.
                There is a way to measure the gap between gear and flywheel however,
                I'm not the one to answer any tech problems

                Comment

                • Paul A.
                  Very Frequent User
                  • April 21, 2021
                  • 227

                  #9
                  Re: Dragging Starter

                  Originally posted by Larry Mulder (20401)
                  Advanced initial timing @16 BTDC is also not helping. You might try and see if reducing to say 12 degrees helps any. If so, centrifugal advance curve can be re-adjusted to keep total number the same.

                  I would also inquire to see if your local starter shop can rebuild for additional load/torque. I had this done for my small block car...........but it was essentially rebuilt to big block specs. But perhaps your rebuilder knows of a few tricks that still can be done.

                  Larry

                  Comment

                  • Timothy B.
                    Extremely Frequent Poster
                    • April 30, 1983
                    • 5177

                    #10
                    Re: Dragging Starter

                    Give some thoughts to a stock distributor with the stock advance curve and vacuum advance. At sixteen degrees initial advance when hot seems way to much for a 390hp engine. The vacuum advance distributor will allow lower initial timing and when the engine starts you will get that 12-15* timing back from the vacuum advance. Combine that with the factory 6-8* initial and you will have 21-23* idle timing.

                    Comment

                    • Paul A.
                      Very Frequent User
                      • April 21, 2021
                      • 227

                      #11
                      Re: Dragging Starter

                      Originally posted by Timothy Barbieri (6542)
                      Give some thoughts to a stock distributor with the stock advance curve and vacuum advance. At sixteen degrees initial advance when hot seems way to much for a 390hp engine. The vacuum advance distributor will allow lower initial timing and when the engine starts you will get that 12-15* timing back from the vacuum advance. Combine that with the factory 6-8* initial and you will have 21-23* idle timing.

                      Comment

                      • Mark E.
                        Extremely Frequent Poster
                        • April 1, 1993
                        • 4498

                        #12
                        Re: Dragging Starter

                        Too much initial timing was my initial thought too. As a test, set initial at factory spec (probably 4 to 8 degrees), disconnect the VAC and see what happens.
                        Your distributor only has 20 degrees of total centrifugal advance, so don't leave the timing like this after testing.
                        Mark Edmondson
                        Dallas, Texas
                        Texas Chapter

                        1970 Coupe, Donnybrooke Green, Light Saddle LS5 M20 A31 C60 G81 N37 N40 UA6 U79
                        1993 Coupe, 40th Anniversary, 6-speed, PEG 1, FX3, CD, Bronze Top

                        Comment

                        • Paul A.
                          Very Frequent User
                          • April 21, 2021
                          • 227

                          #13
                          Re: Dragging Starter

                          Originally posted by Mark Edmondson (22468)
                          Too much initial timing was my initial thought too. As a test, set initial at factory spec (probably 4 to 8 degrees), disconnect the VAC and see what happens.
                          Your distributor only has 20 degrees of total centrifugal advance, so don't leave the timing like this after testing.
                          Hi Mark, as described on above post. The distributor in the car now has no vac advance canister. Factory setting do not apply. If I retard to those numbers it will stall. At least until I replace the distributor. I’ve be searching for a GM 1111141 or comparable. Pic below is what’s in Corvette at present from p o. Wouldn’t a performance cam and or distributor such as this one increase or change original timing?

                          Attached Files

                          Comment

                          • Mark E.
                            Extremely Frequent Poster
                            • April 1, 1993
                            • 4498

                            #14
                            Re: Dragging Starter

                            Paul,

                            With regards to the starter "dragging", we're concerned with the initial static timing. That can be set to factory spec regardless of the type of distributor or cam.

                            Once you eliminate (or correct) initial static timing as a cause of the starting issue, and assuming the car is street driven, consider installing a distributor with a VAC. Without vacuum advance, the engine is running too retarded during low load, high vacuum conditions.
                            Mark Edmondson
                            Dallas, Texas
                            Texas Chapter

                            1970 Coupe, Donnybrooke Green, Light Saddle LS5 M20 A31 C60 G81 N37 N40 UA6 U79
                            1993 Coupe, 40th Anniversary, 6-speed, PEG 1, FX3, CD, Bronze Top

                            Comment

                            • Paul A.
                              Very Frequent User
                              • April 21, 2021
                              • 227

                              #15
                              Re: Dragging Starter

                              Originally posted by Mark Edmondson (22468)
                              Paul,

                              With regards to the starter "dragging", we're concerned with the initial static timing. That can be set to factory spec regardless of the type of distributor or cam.

                              Once you eliminate (or correct) initial static timing as a cause of the starting issue, and assuming the car is street driven, consider installing a distributor with a VAC. Without vacuum advance, the engine is running too retarded during low load, high vacuum conditions.
                              Mark, Thanks for that info. This past few days I was lucky enough to find a GM rebuilt distributor 1111141 for my year engine. Found him on Corvette Forum. He does have other model distributors, so if anyone is interested let me know.

                              Comment

                              Working...

                              Debug Information

                              Searching...Please wait.
                              An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because you have logged in since the previous page was loaded.

                              Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                              An unexpected error was returned: 'Your submission could not be processed because the token has expired.

                              Please push the back button and reload the previous window.'
                              An internal error has occurred and the module cannot be displayed.
                              There are no results that meet this criteria.
                              Search Result for "|||"